Albums Songs Releases Events Lists Members Activity ✦ Plus

✦ Plus Albums Songs Releases Events Lists Members Activity

Jukebox — a diary for everything you listen to.

Albums Songs Lists Members Profile

Catalog, artwork and previews provided courtesy of iTunes / Apple Music. Sample content is labelled.

Terms Privacy Copyright Contact Instagram TikTok

A BR, KR, & HB Production

Albums Songs Releases Events Lists Members Activity ✦ Plus

✦ Plus Albums Songs Releases Events Lists Members Activity

I Couldn't Believe It Was True by Eddy Arnold • Jukebox

Preview provided courtesy of iTunes.

4.8K

listens

137

on lists

1.3K

loves

Sample

Song

I Couldn't Believe It Was True

by Eddy Arnold · from Texarkana Baby

1960Country2:40Track 12

Play 30-second preview

Courtesy of Apple Music

Your rating

What people are saying

Review by Tomasz W.★★★★Sample

“I Couldn't Believe It Was True” at 2am with headphones on is a religious experience.

3.0K likes

Review by Jules Archer★★★★½Sample

Front half: perfect. Back half: also perfect. I'm annoyed.

354 likes

Also on Texarkana Baby

Tracklist

Rate each song as you listen

1
Boquet of Roses
sample avg 3.4
2:32
2
Each Minute Seems a Million Years
sample avg 3.8
2:49
3
Don't Bother to Cry
sample avg 3.5
2:33
4
All Alone in This World Without You
sample avg 4.0
2:35
5
Texarkana Baby
sample avg 3.8
2:41
6
That's How Much I Love You
sample avg 2.9
3:12
7
My Heart Cries for You
sample avg 3.1
2:28
8
Chained to a Memory
sample avg 4.0
2:44
9
It Makes No Difference Now
sample avg 3.4
2:37
10
What Is Life Without Love
sample avg 3.0
2:47
11
What a Fool I Was
sample avg 3.2
2:59
12
I Couldn't Believe It Was True
sample avg 3.6
2:40
13
Anytime
sample avg 3.1
2:52
14
I'll Hold You In My Heart
sample avg 3.9
2:42
15
Molly Darling
sample avg 3.8
3:00
16
Will the Circle Be Unbroken
sample avg 3.7
3:13
17
I'm Thinking Tonight of My Blue Eyes
sample avg 2.9
3:08
18
To My Sorrow
sample avg 3.0
2:53

Your rating

Ratings

3.0K ratings

Sample Sample ratings, not real votes

3.6out of 5

5★

4★

3★

2★

1★

C

Review by Cass Moreno★★★Sample

I respect it more than I love it. “I Couldn't Believe It Was True” is undeniable though.

298 likes

Review by DeShawn Price★★★Sample

Overhyped? Maybe. Did I still cry at “I Couldn't Believe It Was True”? Also maybe.

25 likes

Review by Oskar Lind★★½Sample

Everyone in my group chat loves this and I feel like I'm being gaslit.

10 likes