Albums Songs Releases Lists Members Activity

Albums Songs Releases Lists Members Activity

Jukebox — a diary for everything you listen to.

Albums Songs Lists Members Profile

Catalog, artwork and previews provided courtesy of iTunes / Apple Music. Sample content is labelled.

Terms Privacy Copyright Contact

A BR, KR, & HB Production

Albums Songs Releases Lists Members Activity

Albums Songs Releases Lists Members Activity

That's When I'll Care by Selena Gomez & benny blanco • Jukebox

Preview provided courtesy of iTunes.

3.1K

listens

63

on lists

1.2K

loves

Sample

Song

That's When I'll Care

by Selena Gomez & benny blanco · from I Said I Love You First... And You Said It Back

2025Pop3:05Track 15Explicit

Play 30-second preview

Courtesy of Apple Music

Your rating

What people are saying

Review by Oskar Lind★★★

Your rating

Ratings

2.0K ratings

Sample Sample ratings, not real votes

3.4out of 5

5★

4★

3★

2★

1★

Sample

Solid, but I keep skipping “That's When I'll Care”. Sorry Selena Gomez & benny blanco.

3.9K likes

Review by Tomasz W.★★★★Sample

Took me three listens. By the third, “That's When I'll Care” had moved in and started paying rent.

3.1K likes

Review by Yuki Tanaka★★★★Sample

The production on this is so warm it feels like sitting next to a radiator in January.

2.7K likes

Review by Jules Archer★★★Sample

the highs are high but it sags in the middle. still coming back for “That's When I'll Care” though.

503 likes

Review by Mira Okafor★★★½Sample

Overhyped? Maybe. Did I still cry at “That's When I'll Care”? Also maybe.

106 likes

Also on I Said I Love You First... And You Said It Back

Tracklist

Rate each song as you listen

1
I Said I Love You First
sample avg 4.1
0:44
2
Younger And Hotter Than Me
sample avg 3.0
3:10
3
Call Me When You Break Up
sample avg 3.8 · Selena Gomez, benny blanco & Gracie Abrams
2:07
4
Ojos Tristes
sample avg 3.5 · Selena Gomez, benny blanco & The Marías
3:22
5
Don’t Wanna CryE
sample avg 2.9
3:28
6
Sunset Blvd
sample avg 3.0
2:48
7
CowboyE
sample avg 3.0
3:04
8
Bluest Flame
sample avg 3.8
2:43
9
How Does It Feel To Be ForgottenE
sample avg 3.0
2:41
10
Do You Wanna Be Perfect
sample avg 3.2
0:38
11
You Said You Were SorryE
sample avg 3.9
3:00
12
I Can’t Get Enough (feat. Tainy)
sample avg 3.9 · benny blanco, Selena Gomez & J Balvin
2:38
13
Don’t Take It Personally
sample avg 4.0
2:35
14
Scared Of Loving YouE
sample avg 3.4
1:50
15
That's When I'll CareE
sample avg 3.4
3:05
16
TalkE
sample avg 3.9
2:13
17
Stained
sample avg 4.0 · Selena Gomez
3:27
18
Bluest Flame (DJ Sliink Remix)
sample avg 3.9
2:45
19
How Does It Feel To Be Forgotten (Live From Vevo)E
sample avg 2.9
2:28
20
Call Me When You Break Up (Acoustic Version)
sample avg 3.4 · Selena Gomez, benny blanco & Gracie Abrams
2:48
21
Cowboy (GloRilla Remix)E
sample avg 3.5 · Selena Gomez, benny blanco & GloRilla
2:44
22
Guess You Could Say I’m In Love
sample avg 3.9
3:13